There are actually two stereotypes within this image, which is a still from one of the Karate Kid movies. The first is that of the Zen Buddhist who tends to his bonsai tree. Bonsai trees require a lot of time and attention to detail in order to sculpt into the shape the sculptor envisions. This fits nicely into something Brad Warner mentioned, “Everything you have, whether it’s money or stuff, is an obligation. It is as much your duty to care for and nurture any object you own as it would be if that object were your child”(22). In the Karate Kid movies (the originals anyway, I don’t know about the new one) Mr. Miyagi is always trimming his bonsai trees. Not that Mr. Miyagi is really a Zen Buddhist, but you have to admit that his teachings to “Daniel-san” definitely have a peaceful, almost Zen quality to them. The first thing I personally think of when I see a bonsai tree (after Karate Kid, of course) is Buddhism, since in many movies, TV shows, etc, Buddhists usually seem to be either meditating in some temple, or trimming their bonsai trees. This is not just a stereotype, however; according to www.bonsaigardener.org, it was Zen Buddhists who first introduced the bonsai tree to the Japanese. The Japanese then introduced the art form to the rest of the world, but it seems to have originated with Buddhists.
The second stereotype is that of the monk who is a master at martial arts. Again, I don’t think that Mr. Miyagi was actually a Buddhist, but it wouldn’t surprise me much if that is what his character was based on. I believe another example of this was the movie “Bulletproof Monk” with Chow Yun-Fat, in which Yun-Fat is a monk who also happens to be an undefeatable martial arts master. I highly doubt that there are many Buddhists who know any martial arts. Something I read in the introduction of Brad Warner’s book instantly reminded me of the training Mr. Miyagi gives to Daniel-san, though: “Zen is essentially a ‘back to basics’ view of Buddhism that emerged in China maybe a thousand years or so after Buddha died”(pg.X). Mr. Miyagi’s teachings are very much a “back to basics” form of karate, as he makes Daniel-san perform tasks such as waxing his car and painting his fence in order to learn blocking from muscle-memory. This, plus Mr. Miyagi’s Zen-like attitude, very much reminded me of the stereotype of the fighting monk.
I think your stereotype of Buddhists and the bonsai tree is something that most people wouldn't think of. Also, it's nice to see that I'm not the only one who talked about the stereotype of monks as martial arts masters. "Bulletproof Monk" is a great example, and I'm surprised that it never crossed my mind.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your blog and think you did a nice job. The stereotype of Buddhists with their bonsai trees and the martial-arts-master-monks were two stereotypes that I didn't think of. Which is weird because as soon as I read your blog, I thought "Oh hey, so true!"... guess I just never took the time to ponder it.
ReplyDeleteI felt that you organized your blog well. Good job. :)
P.S. The link that you put in for the bonsai gardener is spelled wrong, so it doesn't work. I wanted to take a look at it.
Yes the amount of time to sculpt one of those trees would greatly reduce the time to practice ones religion. Its an oxy-moron to think a Zen Buddhist would chose to tend to their bonsai trees rather than practice Buddhism. And for Buddhist being martial artist, I felt like Bruce Lee solidified this stereotype for me as a child. And just like Laura, when I read these I was like "Duh, Why didn't I think of those?" Great choices, great pic and though its a little off topic its a great movie too.
ReplyDeleteSo, I am confused now. Buddhists are supposed to follow non attachment. Warner said that everything you have, you must tend to. Is that not like having an attachment? If you have things, you are attached to them, and you are obligated to take care of them. If you were not attached to something, you would not have an obligation or sense of duty to take care of those possessions.
ReplyDelete